Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Welch's avatar

Third Sunday currently penciled in for 8 pm ET.

Tyler GM's avatar

Thanks lads - I read the NYT and Guardian reviews of Nellie’s book, and though not generally surprised at the tenor, I am bamfoozled (just made that up) at how poorly written and conceived both are. In the former, one of the authors chief complaints is that Nellie Bowles is nasty and vicious. Meanwhile, the tone of the review is clearly that of a pissed off writer, hardly objective, the review feels almost personal, like Nellie insulted her mom or something. The latter review comes off similarly pissed, and devolves into educating us on “facts” about trans people, of course without citing a source for these facts, the same charge the author cites Bowles for. There is also an air of superiority and moral certainty in each of these reviews, the same air I’m sure that polluted the NYT ahead of Bari and Nellie’s departure.

I’ve not gotten to read her book yet, but if it’s anything like her TGIF column I expect to thoroughly enjoy it - she is sharp and hilarious. I think the big picture here is that die hard lefty’s can’t stand when their own defect to a more reasoned and nuanced “side”, especially when that defection comes with success and the praise of a much more diverse readership than that of these aggrieved reviewers.

39 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?