Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rageforthemachine's avatar

Let's do a reductio ad absurdum here. Let's assume for the sake of argument that there is in fact a cabal of powerful right-wingers who have as a goal the removal of all black peoples from positions of power in the U.S. and Chris Rufo is their champion. How did that play out in this scenario?

Claudine Gay is a completely innocent scholar whom made a couple of minor attribution errors that were seized upon by the mob who viewed her unfortunate Congressional testimony as the perfect time to pounce and bring another down?

The racist cabal then stormed the offices of Harvard's Board, presenting their completely inconsequential evidence, and demanded Gay become a sacrificial lamb or they would, what? Cut off the meager funds that barely keep Harvard afloat? Withdraw the right-wing support that is so vital to Harvard's core mission? Write op-eds critical of DEI, because DEI is in such a precarious position at our higher institutions of learning that one nasty article in National Review or First Things would be enough to bring it down? Expose Claudine Gay for doing nothing wrong, because we all know being an educated, upper-class black American is the most precarious position in America, especially in academia?

The scenario they are trying to paint is Claudine Gay is a completely innocent victim, and Harvard University is simply powerless to defend her in the wake of the all-powerful juggernaut that is Chris Rufo and the anti-DEI crowd. The problem with the Kendi style arguments is they are increasingly becoming positions of complete blind faith, totally divorced from any actual description of reality.

Expand full comment
Kathleen's avatar

A shame the latest Ask a Jew (with Mike Pesca!) dropped a day too late to be included in the weekend links. Mike has some especially thought-provoking ideas towards the end about the new American age of decadence and how that contrasts with Israel’s state of... everything.

https://open.substack.com/pub/askajew/p/pizza-bagels-with-mike-pesca?r=7enhd&utm_medium=ios&utm_campaign=post

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts