The "being white and adopting non-white children is white supremacy actually" discourse is so disturbing and honestly kind of underrated in terms of deranged leftoid takes that seeped into the culture during 2020.
Amy Coney Barrett was a focal point for this when these psychos discovered she had adopted two children from Hati which was apparently a "kidnapping" and linked to colonialism in some way? Yeah those kids would have been better off staying in Hati a notoriously stable and safe country.
This sentiment goes back to the 90s actually. We wanted children and went through the adoption process because we couldn’t have biological children.
We were living in Minnesota at the time and the state board insisted adoption had to be by race. That’s why we ultimately adopted from overseas (we didn’t want to wait five to six years for a white child to become available).
If you adopt a child of another race, you have an obligation to introduce them to their culture as well as your own. However, it’s absurd to think children do better in orphanages or foster care than a loving home.
You have an obligation to care for the child, love them as your own, and raise them as you see fit. Nothing more, nothing less. You should introduce them to other cultures to broaden their lives and perspectives. But their culture is your culture, for so long as they live under your roof, and becomes what it will be as they grow to live on their own. That's up to them. Trying to force something else is a mistake, and can't be anything but a silly falsehood.
I agree with you up to a point. My children, now in their 30s, are thriving and happy. They do not question that they are ours and have thus far exhibited no regret about their adoptions, unlike the scare stories you read in mainstream media.
We introduced them to their native culture because we had friends from those cultures. We also encouraged them to attend a camp for adoptees from their culture. They went once, said they didn't want to go again, and that was that. We never pushed it, but we did acknowledge that they look a certain way and would be perceived at first as being from a different culture than the one they were raised in.
Yep totally agree. A friend of mine fostered kids and they had babies who were waiting for adoption but no acceptable families were available for the mixed race babies, because social services would only let them go to mixed families. This meant that babies stayed in foster care longer and weren’t in stable family homes.
Let’s continue to make specious, abstract concepts of perfection the enemy of actual, irl good. The gift from the progressive left that keeps on giving.
A true white supremacist would never adopt a black child. That is an absurd concept. How could you face your fellow white supremacists when you show up to a rally with your black child?
I’ve got many criticisms of David French these days, but the notion that he would adopt a child as a “trinket” is repugnant. He’s a fundamentally decent and humane man.
I agree. I like French a lot but I don’t agree with his conservative opinions on many issues. But what we have here is a family doing an extremely noble act. I try to avoid looking at the comments on X. Made the mistake of looking at some of the right wing low life calling him woke and not a conservative. I’m glad X is not real life.
And the fact that he was getting called out in that clip for talking about an area where his perspective changed is infuriating. How many people in the public sphere are willing to show a little humility and engage with “the other side” in good faith?
Guys, I just finished listening to Douglas Murray’s On Democracies and Death Cults. It made me wonder, with all of your coverage of Israel, why has Douglas not been invited on (maybe he has and declined,I have no idea) to discuss it.
I know he’s somewhat of a controversial person. Think he’s also one of the most maligned people I have ever come across. Like, 2018 Jordan Peterson (before he lost a bit more than a step, and started becoming very political) X 2 level maligned.
Think he is the best speaker I have heard in current public life. I think his writing is beautiful. And on Israel specifically, he is one of the only people who was on the ground immediately in the aftermath, with a very good amount of prior war journalism experience, that then chose to write at length about what happened.
I know you had a pre-Oct 7 talk with him. Honestly I have no memory of how it went although I must have listened to it. You all are my favorite podcast and he’s my favorite public intellectual. Maybe that went horribly wrong and I’ve forgotten.
I need to go back and listen! He seems to have taken a bit of a step back since that disastrous shit throwing Rogan interview. Has he just not come forward wanting to do another?
I could be wrong but I think he came on after Rogan (among many times). Course, Murray appears on a lot of other podcasts I happen to listen to so I could be conflating things.
Not sure he was doing journalism on the ground embedded with the IDF.. it’s more like he works for the state of Israel.. or is this just a charity gig he does on the side?
I mean I would call it advocacy journalism at the very least..
He is a brilliant guy with some truly terrible views. I would go so far as to call him illiberal in his views on western civilization and immigration. He has called for anyone waving a Hamas flag to be deported for example. His anti immigrant views basically echo someone like Tommy Robinson. He supports Trump, Orban, Bibi, I think it's fair to call him far right.
However that is just like my opinion man.. you have to ask, how did he end up is this position of Israel's most ardent public defender? Who is paying to do this or is it charity?
The same goes for John Spencer.. where did he come from? Why the media blitz from the very start of the war?
It's just propaganda, you can agree with Israel's goals or not, but Murray is not just some random actor is this, and if he is a journalist, he is a very biased one.
If there's one thing we in Altadena and the Palisades would like the rest of the nation to know, it's this:
Both fires were avoidable, man-made disasters, caused by negligence and mismanagement. It should be an ENORMOUS story with people getting impeached but instead, we're getting distracting stories about crazy arsonists, climate change, and property tax deferrals. It took 15 months of begging for the AG to launch an investigation.
One upside: LATimes has done some great investigative reporting.
A few facts:
- The Eaton fire was started by Southern California Edison. SCE has acknowledged that power transmission lines decommissioned in the 1970s were the likely cause of the fire. I've seen the evidence--it shows that SCE systematically shirked legally-mandated maintenance for decades which directly caused the Eaton fire. 9,000 structure (7,000 homes) were destroyed, 13 people were killed.
- The State and the County systematically fail to oversee SCE which ought to be part of the deal if you're going to grant a monopoly and force millions of citizens to use a service.
- The LACo Office of Emergency Management had its budget gutted in recent years, and appears to have been utterly unprepared. As a result:
- The west side of Altadena (where the majority of the destruction occurred) did not receive any evacuation alerts. 13 people died.
- The LATimes has reported that there was NO fire fighting equipment present in West Altadena. That same report indicates there were scores of fire trucks in East Altadena (LATimes got access to GPS equipment tracking data).
- The Palisades fire started when a PREVIOUS fire (the Jan 1 Lachman fire -- the probable arson) reignited. Recently, LAFD personnel who were on the scene of Lachman have testified that they found areas where embers were still ignited, and that the chain of command was informed. Recovered text messages corroborate this.
- Palisades ran out of water because one of its main reservoirs was empty--it had been empty for 18 months for "maintenance."
- LAFD stopped fighting the Palisades fire before it was out. Recovered texts messages from Mayor Bass indicates that she has suppressed evidence of mismanagement for fear of liability.
So when CA officials claim "there's nothing we could have done--there was too much wind" or whatever, it's bullshit. A nearby, 60-yo neighbor saved three houses BY HIMSELF with a garden hose and buckets of pool water.
I hate SCE with a passion. Talk about a corp committed to covering up their lack of updating. We lived through the Thomas fire and the way those rat bastards handled that confirmed for me that they are, indeed, in league with something much more dangerous than Satan.
I’m sorry that happened to you and your town. SCE is vile and while I don’t believe in Satan, part of me hopes there is a hell for Pedro Pizarro and Steven Powell. The evidence of SCE’s negligence in the Eaton fire beggars belief.
There’s literally no way to stop a fire like that once it gets going. If you read any history of the la basin you know it burns.. it always has.
no doubt, failing infrastructure plays a role, power lines in the air are a weak point that can and will fail.
The real problem is that especially in these older neighborhoods and people have these beautiful gardens and trees. This act like a giant web that the fire can Easily jump from structure to structure.
I recommend this guy's little YouTube channel if you are interested in fires in California, this is a good episode to start goes into detail about these fires
With respect, you’re out of your element. My 63-yo neighbor Fillipo -literally- saved three houses single-handedly with a hose and water from his pool while our entire neighborhood burned around him. Similar examples abound in Altadena and Palisades. In the Palisades, a private fire fighting company saved Palisades Village while everything around it burned.
In Altadena on Christmas tree lane, everything immediately upwind of the massive deodars burned and everything immediately downwind survived. The deodars themselves are -unscathed-. On our property, the only trees and garden matter that burned were those immediately adjacent to our house. A neighbor three doors down has a massive lot heavily treed with oaks—her house burned but the trees and her garden survived and are now thriving.
Both fires ignited due to (different forms of) human negligence. In Altadena, it was not the result of -elevated- lines, it was the result improperly maintained grounding on transmission towers resulting in (known hazard) molten metal raining down on improperly maintained chaparral below the tower—I’ve seen the evidence and it’s clear.
On the west side of Altadena where my house was and the majority of the destruction occurred, there appears to have been NO FIREFIGHTING PRESENCE. East Altadena, which had about 50 fire trucks present, largely survived.
The conditions were exceptionally dangerous on Jan 7 and decades of neglect in both localities led to an abundance of fuel, but we had a week of advance warning and the parties responsible for fire mitigation and fighting were absent. LA is not special—if you read any history you know that all human civilizations are subject to natural disasters. Governments ALWAYS claim that the devastation was unavoidable. But the difference here is that LA has decided to emulate Bangladesh in its response to nature, instead of emulating Japan.
Phoebe Robinson, your Instagram troll, is not a serious person. Just a quick view of her profile and view of a couple of her other videos, she appears to be playing a character to promote her comedy career. Also, the views on her post with David French are less than with her usual views/engagement. While the raw number seems large, it's not really even viral for her. She has nearly 500k followers and rage bait is her product.
She's not worth highlighting or engaging with in any sort of intellectual way.
Thank you Michael for having the courage to comment on the astonishing Meghn Kelly 180. She basically blamed any concern or criticism of Islam on Israel. Appears to have lost her journalist chops which would have revealed that the vast majority of terrorist attacks across the world, as well as dangerous antisocial/criminal behavior like covering women, FGM, anti western values and killing apostates is inspired by the Islamic religion.
He had an idea to build a ballroom and and arch and to paint a reflecting pool blue. That kid's name was Donald Trump, and the city he invented was Washington DC. This was a great man, a man of vision and guts. And there isn't even a plaque, or a signpost or a statue of him in that town!
Matt, I have to address your continued claim that nobody like Xavier Becerra. There is at least one family in Southern California that absolutely loves him. How do I know? I dated one of them when she was a staff assistant in his DC office when he was in the House. I used to leave my free copies of Reason in random places at her parents house whenever I’d go visit.
If you guys have a Q&A session toward the end of your live show in DC, wouldn't it be funny to shut it all down right before Andrew Heaton gets a chance to ask a question?
So now I'm listening to and watching your reaction to a reaction of an interview you did? What are we doing here gentlemen? I love this show for original discussions with interesting people (like David French!), not to get dragged into the gutter with the rif raf on Instagram. Nothing from the time burned on that clip was insightful.
Phoebe Robinson a.k.a dope queen is a comedian apparently. Her latest special, "I don't wanna work anymore" is about the "pit falls of hustle culture". A portion of her Instagram posts are 30 second clips of white guys saying something that she responds with a signature "no, bitch!" as she did with David.
If I didn't know this about her I'd assume she was a random crazy person ranting about David in a one off response. Turns out, she knows exactly what she's doing and now her response to David is fucking disgusting. She's a piece of shit "comedian" whose comedy I assume gets a lot of claps and not a lot of laughs. What's funny and infuriating is that David would defend her freedom of speech when she absolutely wouldn't hesitate to shout him down and call him out for hate speech or some crap.
My take on her rant was that it descended into a ridiculous farce that makes you forget the point she is making and laugh only at her. Maybe that’s her desire for furthering her comedy career. Must admit I was laughing at her calling white men, bitches. Forgot all about the French adoption story.
Yeah, my take reads as a angry screed, probably took it a bit too seriously. It did make me laugh when I saw the clip, calling him a bitch with an extreme close up on her face was pretty fuckin funny.
The "being white and adopting non-white children is white supremacy actually" discourse is so disturbing and honestly kind of underrated in terms of deranged leftoid takes that seeped into the culture during 2020.
Amy Coney Barrett was a focal point for this when these psychos discovered she had adopted two children from Hati which was apparently a "kidnapping" and linked to colonialism in some way? Yeah those kids would have been better off staying in Hati a notoriously stable and safe country.
This sentiment goes back to the 90s actually. We wanted children and went through the adoption process because we couldn’t have biological children.
We were living in Minnesota at the time and the state board insisted adoption had to be by race. That’s why we ultimately adopted from overseas (we didn’t want to wait five to six years for a white child to become available).
If you adopt a child of another race, you have an obligation to introduce them to their culture as well as your own. However, it’s absurd to think children do better in orphanages or foster care than a loving home.
Is race the same as culture?
You have an obligation to care for the child, love them as your own, and raise them as you see fit. Nothing more, nothing less. You should introduce them to other cultures to broaden their lives and perspectives. But their culture is your culture, for so long as they live under your roof, and becomes what it will be as they grow to live on their own. That's up to them. Trying to force something else is a mistake, and can't be anything but a silly falsehood.
I agree with you up to a point. My children, now in their 30s, are thriving and happy. They do not question that they are ours and have thus far exhibited no regret about their adoptions, unlike the scare stories you read in mainstream media.
We introduced them to their native culture because we had friends from those cultures. We also encouraged them to attend a camp for adoptees from their culture. They went once, said they didn't want to go again, and that was that. We never pushed it, but we did acknowledge that they look a certain way and would be perceived at first as being from a different culture than the one they were raised in.
I love that and good on you for all of that.
Yep totally agree. A friend of mine fostered kids and they had babies who were waiting for adoption but no acceptable families were available for the mixed race babies, because social services would only let them go to mixed families. This meant that babies stayed in foster care longer and weren’t in stable family homes.
Such social justice! Very progress!
Let’s continue to make specious, abstract concepts of perfection the enemy of actual, irl good. The gift from the progressive left that keeps on giving.
A true white supremacist would never adopt a black child. That is an absurd concept. How could you face your fellow white supremacists when you show up to a rally with your black child?
No guest. The pod is healing.
Really happy but all “lads only" episodes should be Members Only and behind a paywall. Free loaders don't deserve all this!
Free feed is just more interviews with the Mooch until they subscribe.
Alternating Mooch and Michelle Goldberg
We are the resistancelib podcast now! Suck it, Pod Save America!
I’ve got many criticisms of David French these days, but the notion that he would adopt a child as a “trinket” is repugnant. He’s a fundamentally decent and humane man.
I agree. I like French a lot but I don’t agree with his conservative opinions on many issues. But what we have here is a family doing an extremely noble act. I try to avoid looking at the comments on X. Made the mistake of looking at some of the right wing low life calling him woke and not a conservative. I’m glad X is not real life.
And the fact that he was getting called out in that clip for talking about an area where his perspective changed is infuriating. How many people in the public sphere are willing to show a little humility and engage with “the other side” in good faith?
I swear I wrote this before Moynihan said the same thing basically word-for-word.
Guys, I just finished listening to Douglas Murray’s On Democracies and Death Cults. It made me wonder, with all of your coverage of Israel, why has Douglas not been invited on (maybe he has and declined,I have no idea) to discuss it.
I know he’s somewhat of a controversial person. Think he’s also one of the most maligned people I have ever come across. Like, 2018 Jordan Peterson (before he lost a bit more than a step, and started becoming very political) X 2 level maligned.
Think he is the best speaker I have heard in current public life. I think his writing is beautiful. And on Israel specifically, he is one of the only people who was on the ground immediately in the aftermath, with a very good amount of prior war journalism experience, that then chose to write at length about what happened.
I know you had a pre-Oct 7 talk with him. Honestly I have no memory of how it went although I must have listened to it. You all are my favorite podcast and he’s my favorite public intellectual. Maybe that went horribly wrong and I’ve forgotten.
It was great, actually!
I need to go back and listen! He seems to have taken a bit of a step back since that disastrous shit throwing Rogan interview. Has he just not come forward wanting to do another?
I could be wrong but I think he came on after Rogan (among many times). Course, Murray appears on a lot of other podcasts I happen to listen to so I could be conflating things.
I’d enjoy him back on the pod. Tyler, I concur on all you expressed here. I regard Douglas Murray as a Righteous Among the Nations.
Not sure he was doing journalism on the ground embedded with the IDF.. it’s more like he works for the state of Israel.. or is this just a charity gig he does on the side?
JFC, this is embarrassing at this point. Go watch Hassan Piker.
I mean I would call it advocacy journalism at the very least..
He is a brilliant guy with some truly terrible views. I would go so far as to call him illiberal in his views on western civilization and immigration. He has called for anyone waving a Hamas flag to be deported for example. His anti immigrant views basically echo someone like Tommy Robinson. He supports Trump, Orban, Bibi, I think it's fair to call him far right.
However that is just like my opinion man.. you have to ask, how did he end up is this position of Israel's most ardent public defender? Who is paying to do this or is it charity?
The same goes for John Spencer.. where did he come from? Why the media blitz from the very start of the war?
It's just propaganda, you can agree with Israel's goals or not, but Murray is not just some random actor is this, and if he is a journalist, he is a very biased one.
-ALTADENA- motherfuckers!
If there's one thing we in Altadena and the Palisades would like the rest of the nation to know, it's this:
Both fires were avoidable, man-made disasters, caused by negligence and mismanagement. It should be an ENORMOUS story with people getting impeached but instead, we're getting distracting stories about crazy arsonists, climate change, and property tax deferrals. It took 15 months of begging for the AG to launch an investigation.
One upside: LATimes has done some great investigative reporting.
A few facts:
- The Eaton fire was started by Southern California Edison. SCE has acknowledged that power transmission lines decommissioned in the 1970s were the likely cause of the fire. I've seen the evidence--it shows that SCE systematically shirked legally-mandated maintenance for decades which directly caused the Eaton fire. 9,000 structure (7,000 homes) were destroyed, 13 people were killed.
- The State and the County systematically fail to oversee SCE which ought to be part of the deal if you're going to grant a monopoly and force millions of citizens to use a service.
- The LACo Office of Emergency Management had its budget gutted in recent years, and appears to have been utterly unprepared. As a result:
- The west side of Altadena (where the majority of the destruction occurred) did not receive any evacuation alerts. 13 people died.
- The LATimes has reported that there was NO fire fighting equipment present in West Altadena. That same report indicates there were scores of fire trucks in East Altadena (LATimes got access to GPS equipment tracking data).
- The Palisades fire started when a PREVIOUS fire (the Jan 1 Lachman fire -- the probable arson) reignited. Recently, LAFD personnel who were on the scene of Lachman have testified that they found areas where embers were still ignited, and that the chain of command was informed. Recovered text messages corroborate this.
- Palisades ran out of water because one of its main reservoirs was empty--it had been empty for 18 months for "maintenance."
- LAFD stopped fighting the Palisades fire before it was out. Recovered texts messages from Mayor Bass indicates that she has suppressed evidence of mismanagement for fear of liability.
So when CA officials claim "there's nothing we could have done--there was too much wind" or whatever, it's bullshit. A nearby, 60-yo neighbor saved three houses BY HIMSELF with a garden hose and buckets of pool water.
Have been blanking on the name for two days! Senility!
I hate SCE with a passion. Talk about a corp committed to covering up their lack of updating. We lived through the Thomas fire and the way those rat bastards handled that confirmed for me that they are, indeed, in league with something much more dangerous than Satan.
I’m sorry that happened to you and your town. SCE is vile and while I don’t believe in Satan, part of me hopes there is a hell for Pedro Pizarro and Steven Powell. The evidence of SCE’s negligence in the Eaton fire beggars belief.
There’s literally no way to stop a fire like that once it gets going. If you read any history of the la basin you know it burns.. it always has.
no doubt, failing infrastructure plays a role, power lines in the air are a weak point that can and will fail.
The real problem is that especially in these older neighborhoods and people have these beautiful gardens and trees. This act like a giant web that the fire can Easily jump from structure to structure.
I recommend this guy's little YouTube channel if you are interested in fires in California, this is a good episode to start goes into detail about these fires
https://www.youtube.com/live/2xsIqqvI98s?si=aXpukMQJOTFpKny3
With respect, you’re out of your element. My 63-yo neighbor Fillipo -literally- saved three houses single-handedly with a hose and water from his pool while our entire neighborhood burned around him. Similar examples abound in Altadena and Palisades. In the Palisades, a private fire fighting company saved Palisades Village while everything around it burned.
In Altadena on Christmas tree lane, everything immediately upwind of the massive deodars burned and everything immediately downwind survived. The deodars themselves are -unscathed-. On our property, the only trees and garden matter that burned were those immediately adjacent to our house. A neighbor three doors down has a massive lot heavily treed with oaks—her house burned but the trees and her garden survived and are now thriving.
Both fires ignited due to (different forms of) human negligence. In Altadena, it was not the result of -elevated- lines, it was the result improperly maintained grounding on transmission towers resulting in (known hazard) molten metal raining down on improperly maintained chaparral below the tower—I’ve seen the evidence and it’s clear.
On the west side of Altadena where my house was and the majority of the destruction occurred, there appears to have been NO FIREFIGHTING PRESENCE. East Altadena, which had about 50 fire trucks present, largely survived.
The conditions were exceptionally dangerous on Jan 7 and decades of neglect in both localities led to an abundance of fuel, but we had a week of advance warning and the parties responsible for fire mitigation and fighting were absent. LA is not special—if you read any history you know that all human civilizations are subject to natural disasters. Governments ALWAYS claim that the devastation was unavoidable. But the difference here is that LA has decided to emulate Bangladesh in its response to nature, instead of emulating Japan.
Every time someone says Ken Griffin I hear Ken Griffey and wonder why Junior is getting picked on in NYC.
That kept happening to me, too!
Phoebe Robinson, your Instagram troll, is not a serious person. Just a quick view of her profile and view of a couple of her other videos, she appears to be playing a character to promote her comedy career. Also, the views on her post with David French are less than with her usual views/engagement. While the raw number seems large, it's not really even viral for her. She has nearly 500k followers and rage bait is her product.
She's not worth highlighting or engaging with in any sort of intellectual way.
Thank you Michael for having the courage to comment on the astonishing Meghn Kelly 180. She basically blamed any concern or criticism of Islam on Israel. Appears to have lost her journalist chops which would have revealed that the vast majority of terrorist attacks across the world, as well as dangerous antisocial/criminal behavior like covering women, FGM, anti western values and killing apostates is inspired by the Islamic religion.
When Moyn first said “gesture politics”, I thought he said, “jester politics”.
The second time I heard correctly, but, I thought the other is still fitting 😆
Cato is supposed to have once said he'd rather people ask why there are no monuments to him than ask why there are.
I think about that a lot when I think of 45/47.
He had an idea to build a ballroom and and arch and to paint a reflecting pool blue. That kid's name was Donald Trump, and the city he invented was Washington DC. This was a great man, a man of vision and guts. And there isn't even a plaque, or a signpost or a statue of him in that town!
Funny re: that reaction to David French. I was assured in this chat that he was a liar and the entire story was fabricated bullshit.
I would absolutely support the Wookie Party
Matt, I have to address your continued claim that nobody like Xavier Becerra. There is at least one family in Southern California that absolutely loves him. How do I know? I dated one of them when she was a staff assistant in his DC office when he was in the House. I used to leave my free copies of Reason in random places at her parents house whenever I’d go visit.
Thank you for your service!
If you guys have a Q&A session toward the end of your live show in DC, wouldn't it be funny to shut it all down right before Andrew Heaton gets a chance to ask a question?
So now I'm listening to and watching your reaction to a reaction of an interview you did? What are we doing here gentlemen? I love this show for original discussions with interesting people (like David French!), not to get dragged into the gutter with the rif raf on Instagram. Nothing from the time burned on that clip was insightful.
Phoebe Robinson a.k.a dope queen is a comedian apparently. Her latest special, "I don't wanna work anymore" is about the "pit falls of hustle culture". A portion of her Instagram posts are 30 second clips of white guys saying something that she responds with a signature "no, bitch!" as she did with David.
If I didn't know this about her I'd assume she was a random crazy person ranting about David in a one off response. Turns out, she knows exactly what she's doing and now her response to David is fucking disgusting. She's a piece of shit "comedian" whose comedy I assume gets a lot of claps and not a lot of laughs. What's funny and infuriating is that David would defend her freedom of speech when she absolutely wouldn't hesitate to shout him down and call him out for hate speech or some crap.
My take on her rant was that it descended into a ridiculous farce that makes you forget the point she is making and laugh only at her. Maybe that’s her desire for furthering her comedy career. Must admit I was laughing at her calling white men, bitches. Forgot all about the French adoption story.
Yeah, my take reads as a angry screed, probably took it a bit too seriously. It did make me laugh when I saw the clip, calling him a bitch with an extreme close up on her face was pretty fuckin funny.
I suspect that if Michele Goldberg said she adopted a black child from Ethiopia, there would be no ranting from Robinson.